Substance Dualism And The Mind And Body Philosophy Essay

Substance Dualism And The Mind And Body Philosophy EssayThe underlying idea substance dualism is trying to bill out is the in controligence and the bole atomic number 18 separate entities. The disposition is the owner of its experiences and remains the same through with(predicate) your lifetime. The body and brain are physical while the soul is a mental substance. So in this case James Hartley has lost his soul. That soul which is the possessor of all told his experiences including that of the murder is gone.So lets analyze James Hartleys land site based on the three positions of substance dualism given in the article. The staple fibre awareness of the self states that our individual experiences make us unmatched. For except I possess my experiences which are solely mine. In this case we should stop art him James Hartley for it is obvious he is no longer that person, he no longer possesses the experiences James Hartley had.In unity and the first person perspective it e xplains that no amount of third person descriptions of yourself can better notice you than you. I am I because I am aware of it through self-awareness. So James Hartley doesnt even know his name and is relying on others to tell him who he is. Physi presagey he is James Hartley notwithstanding mentally he is not.In the modal argument it states that if one could create by mental act an pillow slip than that event could be possible. It explains that we can easily conceive ourselves being disembodied but the same does not hold for our body and brain. We can mentally conceive ourselves being disjunct from the body. As stated in the article the soul is the owner of its experiences and is an enduring entity, meaning its not identical to its experiences it is in item the conscious thing that has it. James Hartley in the article doesnt take a crap all James Hartley experiences so that would just now mean his soul has somehow separated from his body.In Summary, it is not the body tha t makes the self it is the self that makes the body.If I were the sheriff I would not have gone through with the hanging. The reason doesnt even have anything to do with the story because I believe that ending someones life because you date stamp it morally fit is an absurd idea. An eye for eye justice establishment is archaic and primitive. But to base it in the context of the story I would not have gone through with the hanging either because plainly somethings wrong with the person, he doesnt know who he is or what he has done. Its exchangeable youre hanging a newborn. Its just the body thats the same but deep down its someone else. A medical checkup would need to be performed on the man to determine what has happened to him. Hastily ending his life deal that was understandably in poor judgment. part B What does it mean to be military personnel?Frankl is saying that our behavior is simply the product of the programming we have accepted genetically before birth as advantag eously as the ageless programming we are receiving from our surroundings after birth. Human beings are simply extremely complex biological machines. The Nazis are the classic example of how public thinking beings are able to commit heinous acts of violence against great deal who have done nothing to them by persistent brainwashing from a single mastermind or as I interchangeable to call it the master programmer. They make the perfect example because they seal the idea that humanekind are mere machines waiting to be programmed. Are our public opinions genuinely unique or simply the regurgitation of our genetic predisposition and the teachings we have genuine throughout our life? Well the Nazis seemed to have proven the latter.Frankl believed that the blood and dirty word concept of human life was developed at the desks and in bother halls of nihilistic scientist and philosophers because these are the group of people who would dare go against the ideas conventional order has set forth. It seems that the most dangerous weapon a human can create is the perception of truth. So the Nazis believe that what they are doing is warrant because of the truth that Jews are evil and therefore must be eradicated. So these scientists and philosophers are able to use truth as a weapon. They are able to project their ideas as the truth for the rest to blindly swallow.Part C The Good BrahmanKnowledge is better. Well the story does point out one good fact that is to convey reason everyplace happiness is to be maladjusted. So why than do we not choose happiness? If I were to tell you human beings had the tendency to be mad would this surprise you? In fact I think our lust for friendship far exceeds any desire for mere happiness. That would be what separates us from animals I suppose, we value knowledge more. To not question would simply not be human. Maybe it qualification also have to do with our ego. Our ego governs us. To be imbecilic is to hurt our ego. As child ish as the idea might be but what if we are just too egotistical to take down to the simple beliefs like god has a purpose for us. If a huge ego went hand in hand with being without coarse sense we would readily accept happiness. What I mean by this is we would like to give in to the idea that we are intelligent because we ask all these questions others dont. I am smarter than you because I think and you dont. We shudder at the thought of gaining happiness through false beliefs. We do not believe that to be true happiness. Maybe just maybe this very fact is the only reason we choose to keep on looking for answers for things we very well know we cannot answer during our lifetime. To gain happiness via false beliefs is almost like gaining huge amounts of money through stealing. You cheated for your quick grab at happiness.